WARNING - OLD ARCHIVES

This is an archived copy of the Xen.org mailing list, which we have preserved to ensure that existing links to archives are not broken. The live archive, which contains the latest emails, can be found at http://lists.xen.org/
   
 
 
Xen 
 
Home Products Support Community News
 
   
 

xen-devel

Re: Re: [Xen-devel] Why the credit scheduler of xen-3.2.0 can ensure the

To: "zhangxiang" <zhangxiang@xxxxxxxxxx>
Subject: Re: Re: [Xen-devel] Why the credit scheduler of xen-3.2.0 can ensure theI/O fairness?
From: Atsushi SAKAI <sakaia@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
Date: Mon, 26 May 2008 15:50:22 +0900
Cc: xen-devel <xen-devel@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
Delivery-date: Sun, 25 May 2008 23:51:04 -0700
Envelope-to: www-data@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
In-reply-to: <200805261031033492911@xxxxxxxxxx>
List-help: <mailto:xen-devel-request@lists.xensource.com?subject=help>
List-id: Xen developer discussion <xen-devel.lists.xensource.com>
List-post: <mailto:xen-devel@lists.xensource.com>
List-subscribe: <http://lists.xensource.com/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/xen-devel>, <mailto:xen-devel-request@lists.xensource.com?subject=subscribe>
List-unsubscribe: <http://lists.xensource.com/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/xen-devel>, <mailto:xen-devel-request@lists.xensource.com?subject=unsubscribe>
References: <200805261031033492911@xxxxxxxxxx>
Sender: xen-devel-bounces@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Hi, Xiang

  tickling itself exists in first version of credit scheduler. 

changeset: New weighted fair-share CPU scheduler w/ automatic SMP load balancing
changeset 10168:        e539abd27a0f
http://xenbits.xensource.com/xen-unstable.hg?rev=10168

Please check Table.1 and Section4.2 of your citation.

Thanks
Atsushi SAKAI


"zhangxiang" <zhangxiang@xxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

> Hello Atsushi:
> 
> Thank you very much for your reply!
> I have already read that patch. In the paper "Scheduling I/O in Virtual 
> Machine Monitors", the author said that fixing event channel notification can 
> only ensure the I/O fairness with the tickling scheduler disable, and the 
> scheduler tickling is the culprit of the I/O unfairness even the event 
> channel code is fixed (Please see the Section 6.1). Although Xen-3.2.0 have 
> fixxed the event channel code, it does not disable the scheduler tickling. So 
> I think there should be something else xen-3.2.0 has done.
> Thank you again for your help.
> 
> Xiang ZHANG
> National Research Center for Intelligent Computing Systems
> Institute of Computing Technology, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing,
> P.R.China
> 
> 
> 
> 
> 
> キ「シ扤優辧廛\xB3 Atsushi SAKAI
> キ「ヒヘハアシ茱コ 2008-05-26 09:56:35
> ハユシ扤優辧廛\xB3 zhangxiang
> ウュヒヘ」コ xen-devel
>
\xBE 
\xBE 皮\xAC 懃瘤\xE7
\xBE 
\xBE 搶\xF5 鼈阨趙 黼\xE5 \x{6285}\xE5 肬跛阯蜴\xE7 鞜\x{623e}莅
\xBE 
\xBE 竏瘤艱黼扤 會閭纉\xF3 纐緕\xF4 竏瘤鈬踈 鈿扤肅竅扤闔\xF3 蜴 鳫扤筬鳫砠\xEE 闥粤鬯
\xBE 竏瘤艱黼\xF4 害敢  傑絮禧箘過霞
\xBE 蔗扤痕扤緕砠\x{63ed}扤緕齒\x{235c4}竇\x{fa33}闕扤蜴扤\x{2471}扤扤賢扤隨蒟崇纐扤聽宴銀芦甓\xE2
\xBE 
\xBE 壽瘤謫
\xBE 藻齦鼈\xE9 啻冒\xC9
\xBE 
\xBE 
\xBE 
\xBE \x{266e}葹鈑扤瘤腆  綬葹鈑扤瘤臉扤扤扤扤扤 \xBE 扤阡綺
\xBE 
\xBE \xBE 斐跛鍖 纐纈扤閼扤
\xBE \xBE 
\xBE \xBE \xC9 葹扤 鱚竇銓踟 鱚痲 \x{6285}\xE5 鞜鞳\xF2 \x{2297}竏繖扤蜴\xE7 逼\xCF 蜴 帷鶯扤\xEC 浴竏蜴\xE5 酪鉗扤鴦↑ 
扤蜒\xE8 黶蜆 \x{6285}癆 \x{6285}\xE5 竰繖蜚 黹蒹糒跂\xF2 閹 扤\xEE 竅\xEE 鈿\xF4 緕齦鱚 \x{6285}\xE5 薇\xEF 聲蜥鈬齠\x{32b1}跂癈\xE5 
黼\xE5 \x{6285}\xE5 鍋苺鱚 \xB3 蜴 \x{6285}\xE5 鞜鞳鬧\xAE 壽\xE5 癜\x{6285}闥 黶蜆 \x{6285}癆 扤\xF5 竅\xEE 痺蓍纐\xE5 \x{6285}\xE5 
薇\xEF 聲蜥鈬齠 磔 粡黶碎\xE5 \x{6285}\xE5 黹蒹糒跂\xF2 扤站跚鈑\xAC 瘤\xE4 齒鶯蜴\xE7 \x{6285}\xE5 扤頤 磔 \x{6285}\xE5 
扤跿\xE5 閹 \x{6285}\xE5 竰繖蜚 鱚轣蜴繖\x{32b1}跂癈\xE5 黼\xE5 \x{6285}\xE5 鱚跂扤銓 韶\xF4 肬\xF2 崚徹県\xAE \xC9 葹扤 
纐瘡扤扤\xE4 \x{6285}\xE5 竰繖蜚 黹蒹糒跂\xF2 閹 扤遶凱窺穐 蜚 粹纉 瘍鱚\xE5 扤\x{6285} \x{6285}\xE5 關扤闔 蜴 \x{6285}\xE5 鞜鞳鬯 
\xBE \xBE 
\xBE \xBE 被扤扤鬪 扤緕 \xC9 纐瘡扤扤鈑 \x{6285}\xE5 竰繖蜚 黹蒹糒跂\xF2 閹 扤遶凱荻穐 \x{6285}\xE5 鱚齦踉\xF3 鼈阯 \x{6285}癆 
\x{6285}\xE5 黹蒹糒跂\xF2 竅\xEE 緕齦鱚 \x{6285}\xE5 薇\xEF 聲蜥鈬齠 扤鴒 扤跛\xAE \xC9 粡聿 \x{6285}\xE5 黹蒹籖竰繖蜚\x{fa33} 閹 
\x{6285}\xE5 扤\xEF 扤鴦蜿銖 閹 扤遯 \x{6285}纖 癇\xE5 \x{6285}\xE5 黶辣\xAE 部 黼纃\xF3 \x{6285}癆 \x{6285}\xE5 竰繖蜚 黹蒹糒跂\xF2 閹 
扤遶凱荻\xB0 粹纉 鈿\xF4 齒鶯 \x{6285}\xE5 扤頤 磔 竰繖蜚 闥 粡黶碎\xE5 \x{6285}\xE5 黹蒹糒跂\xF2 扤站跚鈑\xAE 囂 \xC9 
\x{fa16}鈔纈 \x{6285}癆 扤癆 蜊頏阮纃緕\x{63ed} 扤\xEE 葹扤 粹鈬 扤 齒跫扤 \x{6285}蜩 頏閧跂躾
\xBE \xBE 
\xBE \xBE 壽\xE5 纔鞳鱸辣銓 \xC9 葹扤 粹鈬 蜩 癈 肬跛阯鷓
\xBE \xBE 壽\xE5 齷齡纃 葹\xF3 瘤 鼠\xC4 扤扤鳫\xEE 鹸\xB8 頏閭纉齒鬪 看 韆扤蜒瘡 辣迴鴒\xAC 瘤\xE4 \xE1 
秤艨砠\xF4 續蒹鴈續 良樽 \xC9 鴣\xEE 繪艾\xF4 扤\xEE 嵳鵺 瘤\xE4 鴣\xEE 鈬扤纈\xE6 矼釿蓁癇\xEB 黼鞜鱇扤扤 
当纈\xF9 嵳 葹\xF3 瘡迴齡 \x{6285}\xE5 黶辣 矚鈔扤糘\xE8 閹 渦\xB0 翌扤\xAE
\xBE \xBE 
\xBE \xBE 壽瘤\xEB 扤\xF5 扤鴒 逡竏 肬\xF2 扤\x{235c4} 蒹跟\xAE
\xBE \xBE 
\xBE \xBE 懃瘤\xE7 敞僧\xC7
\xBE \xBE 令扤闔瘡 吶黼癇竏 着銓纈 肬\xF2 侮扤跛蜃緕\xF4 衷逅扤蜴\xE7 囮齡纃\xF3
\xBE \xBE 侮齡蜚扤\xE5 閹 衷逅扤蜴\xE7 壹竏鈿跫苹\xAC 宙蜴纉\xE5 巣痲纃\xF9 閹 噬蜈釿纉\xAC 代蜉蜴膃
\xBE \xBE 豫勳宙蜴\xE1



烝烝烝烝烝烝烝烝烝烝烝烝烝烝烝烝烝烝烝烝烝烝烝\xDF
懊遶粤扤\xEC 轣蛹蜴\xE7 跚齡
懊遶粤扤貔扤扤扤扤扤扤扤扤扤\xF8
蔗扤痕扤蜩\x{63ed}扤緕齒\x{235c4}竇\x{fa33}闕扤緕\x{2121}纐繻

<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>